Custodial vs Non-Custodial Wallets: What is the Difference?

Custodial and Non-custodial wallets are popular terms within the blockchain and cryptocurrency ecosystem.

Firstly, have you ever wondered where and how your cryptocurrency is kept?

Token holders can keep their cryptocurrency in various wallets.

However, they can be broadly divided into two groups: custodial wallets and non-custodial wallets.

Both have their pros and cons. Let’s examine their distinctions to help you determine when to employ each.

What is a Custodial Wallet?

A third party, like an exchange or online wallet service, manages and stores the private keys in a custodial wallet.

Users do not control their private keys directly; they rely on the third party for safety.

These wallets offer the convenience of not having to manage your own private keys, but they also come with risks.

Because you entrust a third party with your keys, you are at their mercy if something goes wrong.

If the company managing the keys goes out of business or is hacked, your funds could be at risk.

Hence, it is important to carefully choose a reputable and trustworthy third party to manage them.

Read: All You Need To Know About Cryptocurrency

Advantages of Custodial Wallets

There are several advantages to using custodial wallets, including:

Convenience

One of the main advantages of custodial wallets is that they are often easier to use and set up.

The third party handles technical details like key generation, storage, and transaction management.

This simplifies cryptocurrency management for new crypto users unfamiliar with technical aspects.

Security

Another advantage of custodial wallets is that they can offer added security compared to non-custodial wallets.

The third party ensures key safety using advanced security measures like cold storage and multi-signature technology.

Even if a user’s device is compromised, the keys and funds remain protected.

Ease of use

Custodial wallets typically offer simple, intuitive interfaces for easy cryptocurrency transactions.

This is especially useful for users who prefer a wallet that is easy to use.

Support

Most custodial wallet providers offer customer support, assisting users with technical issues or questions.

This can be especially important for users new to cryptocurrency and may need guidance on managing their funds.

Read: How to Choose the Right Cryptocurrency Wallet for Your Needs

Disadvantages of Custodial Wallets

Loss of control

Users risk losing control of their funds if the third party goes out of business or gets hacked.

This means they do not have direct control over their funds.

Entrusting a third party with private keys poses a risk if they don’t act in the user’s best interest.

Counterparty risk

Because the user relies on a third party to manage their keys and funds, there is a risk that the third party will not act in the user’s best interest.

This could include mismanaging funds, freezing accounts, or failing to provide adequate security.

Lack of privacy

Some custodial wallet providers may have access to the user’s transaction history and other personal information, which could potentially be shared with third parties without the user’s consent.

This could potentially compromise the user’s privacy and security.

Limited functionality

Custodial wallets may have limited functionality as they are typically designed to be easy to use rather than highly customizable.

This can be frustrating for users who want more control over their wallet and its features.

Read: Hot Wallet vs Cold Wallet in Cryptocurrency

What is a Non-Custodial Crypto Wallet? 

A non-custodial crypto wallet is a type of cryptocurrency wallet in which the user holds the private keys and has sole control over them.

This means that the user is responsible for managing and protecting their own keys, rather than relying on a third party to do it for them.

Non-custodial wallets offer the added security and control of not having to trust a third party with your keys.

However, they also come with the added responsibility of managing and protecting your own keys, which can be more challenging for some users.

Overall, non-custodial wallets can be a good option for users who want complete control over their own keys and funds.

Still, it is important to carefully manage and protect your keys to ensure the safety of your funds.

Read: What is an MPC Wallet in Blockchain?

Advantages of Non-Custodial Wallets

Control over keys

One of the main advantages of non-custodial wallets is that the user has complete control over their private keys.

This means that they are not reliant on a third party to keep their keys safe, and they have the added security and peace of mind of knowing that their funds are under their own control.

Increased security

Because the user is responsible for managing and protecting their own keys, non-custodial wallets can offer increased security compared to custodial wallets.

This is because the keys are not stored on a third party’s servers, which reduces the risk of loss or theft due to hacks or other security breaches.

Customization and flexibility

Non-custodial wallets are often more customizable and flexible as the user has complete control over their own keys and can choose the features and functionality that they want.

This can be especially helpful for advanced users who want more control over their wallets.

Privacy

With a non-custodial wallet, the user is in complete control of their keys and personal information, which means they have more control over their privacy and security.

This can be important for users who value their privacy and do not want their transaction history or other personal information to be shared with third parties.

Disadvantages of Non-Custodial Wallets

Responsibility for keys

One of the main disadvantages of non-custodial wallets is that the user is responsible for managing and protecting their own private keys.

This can be challenging for some users, especially if they are unfamiliar with the technical details of cryptocurrency wallets.

It is important for users to carefully manage and protect their keys to ensure the safety of their funds.

Risk of loss or theft

Another disadvantage of non-custodial wallets is that the keys could be lost or stolen if the user’s computer or device is compromised.

This could result in the loss of the user’s funds, and there may be no way to recover them if the keys are lost.

This is a significant risk that users should be aware of before choosing to use a non-custodial wallet.

Limited support

Non-custodial wallets typically do not offer customer support or assistance, which can be frustrating for users who have questions or need help with technical issues.

This means that users are on their own when managing and protecting their keys, and they may need to rely on online forums or other resources for help.

Lack of insurance

Some custodial wallet providers offer insurance to protect users’ funds in the event of loss or theft, but this is typically not available with non-custodial wallets.

This means that the user is fully responsible for protecting their own funds and there is no safety net if something goes wrong.

This is something that users should be aware of before choosing to use a non-custodial wallet.

Key Differences Between Custodial and Non-Custodial Wallets

Custodian of the private key

Who controls the private key is the most important factor to consider when comparing custodial and non-custodial wallets.

A third entity controls the private key in custody wallets.

In contrast, the users provide all blockchain custodian services for non-custodial wallets.

If you wish to launch a wallet that allows consumers to act as their own bank, create non-custodial blockchain wallets (also known as self-custodial wallets).

Security

Sensitive user data for custodial online cryptocurrency wallets is kept in hot and cold storage, both of which are frequently breached by data thieves.

As a result, custodial security is low unless the authoritative party takes significant security measures.

Contrarily, when comparing non-custodial crypto wallets, users retain full access to the data.

This lessens the chance of data theft unless the user discloses the information to someone else or has their device stolen.

Backup and recovery possibility

Regarding backup and recovery capabilities, self-custodial wallets or non-Custodial crypto wallets lag behind Custodial ones.

The Custodial wallets keep the private key. In other words, even if you lose access to data, you can get it back by asking a third party.

Offline accessibility

To access your funding and associated information, you must log in to your Custodial wallet and submit a request to a centralized authority.

Therefore, internet connectivity is essential.

However, non-custodial wallets do not have this requirement.

As a result, non-custodial wallets are a preferable choice if you want to use comprehensive blockchain development capabilities in real time.

Conclusion

The qualities of a wallet that are most important to you will help you decide between a non-custodial and a custodial type.

Newcomers and individuals who appreciate the set-and-forget simplicity of managing their cryptocurrency through an exchange or other centralized wallet provider typically choose custody wallets.

Users who want to exert more control over who has access to their cash should use non-custodial wallets. 

Both wallets have advantages and disadvantages, so consider your comfort level with the aspects that matter to you the most before making a choice.

You should also consider the benefits that each wallet provides, such as the range of supported coins, staking chances, cashback rewards, and crypto debit or credit cards.

Before you go…

Hey, thank you for reading this blog to the end. I hope it was helpful. Let me tell you a little bit about Nicholas Idoko Technologies.

We help businesses and companies build an online presence by developing web, mobile, desktop, and blockchain applications.

We also help aspiring software developers and programmers learn the skills they need to have a successful career.

Take your first step to becoming a programming boss by joining our Learn To Code academy today!

Be sure to contact us if you need more information or have any questions! We are readily available.